Best Roofing Companies in Sanibel, Florida - 8 Compared (2026)
By Shelly Marchetti, Florida homeowner advocate. Reviewed by Hal Winstead, Editor, licensed roofing contractor.
I remember driving over the Sanibel Causeway the week after Ian, past the washout near the old toll plaza, to check on a stilt house on Bougainvillea Drive. The roof wasn't there anymore—just a blue tarp and a pile of shingles in the mangrove scrub. That's when I started keeping a notebook on who actualy showed up, who pulled permits, and who left homeowners stranded with a deposit and a dead phone number.
So for this list, I didn't take anyone's word for it. I ran every company throught the Florida DBPR licence roll and checked each one against the active roster, same as I do for my own clients. Two of the eight below came back with an active roofing licence. Before you trust your drywall or your ceiling joists to anyone, read how I vetted them—and cross-check the current status of every roofing company we list in Sanibel yourself. Storm season gives you no second chances.
Short answer: the 8 best roofing companies in Sanibel, Florida are led by Trademark Roofing, Rooftop Roofing, Inc and McGinn&Lazar Construction. Of the 8 listed here, 2 hold a verified Florida DBPR roofing licence, which is the single check worth doing before anyone climbs on your roof. Rankings below use licence status, review volume, rating and photo evidence — all public, all reproducible.
If you would rather browse the full list rather than my shortlist, every one of them is on the Sanibel roofing companies directory page — this post is the 8 I would call first.
How this list was ranked. Every company here was cross-checked against the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation licence roll; 2 of 8 returned an active roofing licence (type CCC or RC), and the licence number is printed on each entry so you can verify it yourself. After licence status, ordering uses Google review count (capped so a big chain cannot buy the top spot on volume alone), star rating, and whether the company has photos and published hours. Nobody paid to appear on this list.
The 8 Best Roofing Companies Sanibel Florida Has to Offer
1. Trademark Roofing
Florida licence: CCC1333129 (active) · Google rating: 5 from 9 reviews · Based in: 1149 Periwinkle Way #2, Sanibel · Phone: +1 239-747-6145
2. Rooftop Roofing, Inc
Florida licence: CCC1326630 (active) · Google rating: 3.3 from 3 reviews · Based in: 983 Black Skimmer Way, Sanibel · Phone: +1 720-296-3492
3. McGinn&Lazar Construction
Florida licence: not matched in the DBPR roll — ask before hiring · Google rating: 5 from 11 reviews · Based in: 419 Lighthouse Way, Sanibel · Phone: +1 239-472-6390
4. Higher Power Solar & Roofing | Sanibel
Florida licence: not matched in the DBPR roll — ask before hiring · Google rating: 5 from 10 reviews · Based in: 2407 Periwinkle Way Ste 169, Sanibel · Phone: +1 941-347-9639
5. Newport Property Construction
Florida licence: not matched in the DBPR roll — ask before hiring · Google rating: 5 from 7 reviews · Based in: 2440 Palm Ridge Rd #4, Sanibel · Phone: +1 239-376-0027
6. Sunny Sanibel Roofing
Florida licence: not matched in the DBPR roll — ask before hiring · Google rating: 5 from 1 reviews · Based in: 1200 Periwinkle Way Ste 1, Sanibel · Phone: +1 239-932-4986
7. Wildseed Construction, LLC
Florida licence: not matched in the DBPR roll — ask before hiring · Google rating: 5 from 7 reviews · Based in: 760 Vinca Way, Sanibel · Phone: +1 239-994-4581
8. Ulrich Building Company
Florida licence: not matched in the DBPR roll — ask before hiring · Google rating: 5 from 5 reviews · Based in: 2330 Palm Ridge Rd #10, Sanibel · Phone: +1 239-896-7116
How to check any Florida roofer's licence yourself
Search the licence number at the Florida DBPR licence portal. A roofing contractor holds a CCC (certified) or RC (registered) licence. If the number does not return an active record, that is the end of the conversation.
See all roofing companies in Sanibel →